---
title: VFD or soft starter? Choosing the right fit for your equipment
date: 2026-11-02T10:00:00+11:00
author: Karen Heidtmann
canonical_url: "https://cromartyautomation.com.au/news/vfd-or-soft-starter"
section: News
---
#  VFD or soft starter? Choosing the right fit for your equipment 

 

 

 

 

 

   ![ABB drive with hand](https://cromartyautomation.com.au/volumes/images/Products/ABB-Industrial/_2048xAUTO_crop_center-center_70_none/34380/ABB-drive-with-hand.webp) 

A pump that starts abruptly and a fan that runs at full speed despite falling demand present different problems. Both involve motor control, but the right solution depends on what happens during starting, stopping and the hours in between.

Variable frequency drives (VFDs) and soft starters both have a place in industrial operations. Understanding where each fits can help reduce equipment stress, improve process control and avoid spending on capability the application does not need.

---

#### The difference starts with speed control

A soft starter progressively controls the voltage applied to a motor during starting. This limits starting current and softens acceleration, helping reduce mechanical stress on the equipment it drives. Some models also provide controlled stopping.

Once the motor reaches normal operating speed, it generally runs at full supply frequency. A soft starter does not provide continuous speed control.

A VFD varies the frequency and voltage supplied to the motor, allowing its speed to change throughout operation. This is useful where equipment needs to respond to changing demand, such as adjusting pump output to maintain pressure or varying fan speed to suit airflow requirements.

---

### What determines the right choice?

#### How the equipment starts

For equipment that runs at a constant speed, a soft starter may provide the control required.

[ABB’s *Softstarter Handbook*](https://library.e.abb.com/public/6b4e1a3530814df0c12579bb0030e58b/1SFC132060M0201.pdf) gives typical starting currents of seven to eight times nominal motor current for direct-on-line starting, compared with three to five times using a soft starter. Actual values depend on the motor, load and configuration.

The mechanical demands matter too. A loaded conveyor needs enough starting torque to get moving. Simply reducing starting current as far as possible can leave the motor struggling to accelerate.

Starting duration and the number of starts per hour also affect selection. Equipment that starts frequently or takes longer to accelerate may require a different rating from equipment with occasional, straightforward starts.

---

#### How demand changes during operation

Where demand varies, a VFD can match equipment output more closely to the process.

Consider a centrifugal pump whose flow is controlled by partially closing a valve. Depending on the system, reducing pump speed may meet the required flow with less energy than running at full speed and restricting the output.

The [Australian Government’s guidance on motors and variable speed drives](https://www.energy.gov.au/business/equipment-guides/motors-and-variable-speed-drives) notes that a 20% speed reduction can reduce power required by around 50% in suitable pump and fan applications.

That illustrates the potential of speed control; it is not a guaranteed saving for every installation. Actual results depend on the system, its operating limits and how much time it spends at reduced demand. A pump working against substantial static head, for example, needs closer assessment before applying a simple speed-to-power calculation.

For equipment that must run at full speed throughout its operating cycle, the energy-saving case for a VFD may be limited.

---

#### What the existing installation can support

Motor power is only part of the assessment. The required speed range, motor condition, cabling and enclosure conditions also influence the choice.

When considering a VFD, motor suitability and cooling at lower speeds need attention. Where speed responds to a pressure, flow or level measurement, the instrumentation matters as well. The drive needs a reliable measurement and appropriate control settings to respond correctly.

Replacing a failed device is therefore an opportunity to review how the equipment operates, particularly if production requirements have changed since it was installed.

---

#### Commissioning makes the choice work

Once the equipment is selected, its settings need to suit the application. Acceleration times, current limits, motor protection and control signals should be checked against actual operating conditions.

A successful start is only one part of that check. Equipment also needs to respond properly as demand changes, stop as intended and operate within its limits.

For operators, the useful starting question is straightforward: does the equipment need a smoother start, or does the process need ongoing speed control? Answering it properly means looking at the motor, the machinery and the process together.

Cromarty Automation’s Tasmanian technical services team provides instrumentation, calibration and field services to support dependable industrial operations. If you are reviewing an existing motor installation or planning a change, contact our team to discuss your requirements.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  [ ![Cromarty logo](/assets/images/logo-automation-white.svg) ](/) 

 [1300 365 136](tel:1300365136) 

 [](https://www.facebook.com/Cromartys/) [](https://www.linkedin.com/company/cromarty/)
